Jonah in the Bible: The Story, the Whale, and Where It All Came From


Marko Marina Author Bart Ehrman

Written by Marko Marina, Ph.D.

Author |  Historian

Author |  Historian |  BE Contributor

Verified!  See our guidelines

Verified!  See our editorial guidelines

Date written: November 18th, 2026

Date written: November 18th, 2026

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily match my own. - Dr. Bart D. Ehrman

The story of Jonah in the Bible always takes me back to my childhood Sunday classes, where I had the privilege of learning from a wonderful Catholic teacher who genuinely loved what she did. 

I still remember the beautifully illustrated Bible storybooks she would give us to read, especially one featuring a colorful depiction of Jonah and the whale.

The illustrations were so vivid and full of fascinating details that, as a child, I probably spent more time staring at the pictures than actually reading the words! 

There was something captivating about the image of a man swallowed by an enormous sea creature, and I suspect I was hardly the only child whose imagination was captured by this extraordinary biblical tale.

Years later, I approach the story of Jonah in the Bible from a rather different perspective, but it has lost none of its fascination.

If anything, studying the Bible through the lens of modern historical and literary scholarship has made this familiar childhood story even more intriguing. After all, there is much more to the Book of Jonah than its most famous episode. 

Who wrote this unusual biblical book, and when? What kind of story was its ancient author trying to tell? And why do many biblical scholars today believe that its seemingly straightforward narrative is actually a sophisticated work of satire, filled with irony, humor, and unexpected reversals? 

As we’ll discover, the answers reveal a biblical text that is considerably more complex (and perhaps even more entertaining!) than the colorful illustrations I remember from childhood.

But before we embark on the sea with Jonah, why not take another fascinating journey into the origins of the Bible itself? In his 10-lecture online course, The Bible by Committee: How the Pentateuch Was Really Written?, Yale biblical scholar Joel Baden explores one of the most intriguing questions in biblical scholarship: Who actually wrote the first five books of the Bible? 

Through a careful examination of the biblical texts, Baden shows how scholars identify different literary sources and reconstruct the process through which these writings came together. If you've ever wondered how the Bible came to be written, this course offers a fascinating place to begin!

jonah in the bible

Where Is the Story of Jonah in the Bible, and What Happens?

In the book Introduction à l'Ancien Testament (Introduction to the Old Testament), Ernst A. Knauf writes:

(Affiliate Disclaimer: We may earn commissions on products you purchase through this page at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting our site!)

“Unlike other collections of prophetic writings, the Book of Jonah is not a collection of oracles attributed to a prophet who actually lived. Jonah is closer to the genre of the ‘Hebrew novella,’ [nouvelle hébraïque] which is attested on numerous occasions in the Bible (the story of Joseph, the Book of Ruth, the account of Balaam in Numbers 22–24, and the affair of Naboth in 1 Kings 21). Sensible people know that no fish has ever swallowed a prophet and then vomited him, safe and sound, onto a beach. The author of Jonah was well aware of this; he is not trying to make us swallow tall tales, but rather to remind us of some hard truths.” (my translation)

In other words, Knauf argues that the ancient author was not attempting to convince readers that a prophet had literally survived inside an enormous fish. Rather, he was using an extraordinary story to communicate some uncomfortable truths. 

We’ll return to those truths later. First, however, we need to establish where the Book of Jonah appears in the Bible and what exactly happens in its rather unusual narrative.

So, where is Jonah in the Bible? The Book of Jonah belongs to the Hebrew Bible, where it appears among the collection known as the Twelve Minor Prophets. The designation “minor” has nothing to do with the importance of these prophets.

Rather, it reflects the relatively short length of their books compared with those associated with figures such as Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel. Jonah itself contains only four chapters, making it one of the shorter books in this collection. 

Yet it differs significantly from most other prophetic writings. Rather than presenting a collection of divine pronouncements and prophetic speeches, it tells a story about a prophet whose behavior is, to put it mildly, rather peculiar.

The narrative begins when God commands Jonah to travel to Nineveh, the great Assyrian city, and proclaim judgment against its wickedness. Instead of obeying, Jonah boards a ship bound for Tarshish, traditionally associated with a distant location in the western Mediterranean. 

As John J. Collins observes:

Jonah, indeed, is something of an anti-prophet. When the word of the Lord comes to him, bidding him go to Nineveh and cry out against it, he goes instead in the opposite direction, to Tarshish (Spain), to flee from the presence of the Lord. His adventures are the stuff of comic legend. When a storm rises at sea, the sailors cry, each to his own deity. Ecumenical to a fault, they urge Jonah also to pray to his god. This cacophony of prayer fails to produce the desired result, so they resort to lots to determine the cause of the storm.

When the lot identifies Jonah, he acknowledges his responsibility and tells the sailors to throw him overboard. After initially attempting to avoid this drastic solution, they eventually comply, and the storm immediately subsides.

At this point, God appoints an enormous fish to swallow Jonah, who remains inside it for three days and three nights. After Jonah offers a prayer, God commands the fish to vomit him onto dry land.

Having survived this extraordinary experience, Jonah receives God's command a second time and finally travels to Nineveh. 

There, he delivers a remarkably brief warning: in 40 days, the city will be overthrown (3:4). Surprisingly, the inhabitants take his message seriously. From ordinary citizens to the king himself, the Ninevites respond with fasting and repentance, even involving their animals in this extraordinary public display. 

Seeing their response, God decides not to bring upon them the destruction he had threatened. One might expect Jonah to celebrate the success of his prophetic mission.

Instead, he becomes furious. He complains that God's willingness to show mercy was precisely what he had feared all along and even asks to die. The narrative then introduces a plant that provides Jonah with shade, only for God to appoint a worm to destroy it.

Jonah's anger over the plant becomes the occasion for God's final question: if Jonah can care so deeply about a plant, should God not have compassion for the numerous inhabitants of Nineveh? Remarkably, the book ends without telling us how Jonah responds.

As this brief summary suggests, the story of Jonah in the Bible contains considerably more than the famous episode involving an enormous sea creature. 

Indeed, its surprising conclusion raises questions that are arguably more interesting than the fate of the prophet inside the fish. 

But before examining Jonah and the whale more closely, we need to address two fundamental historical questions: Who wrote this book, and when was it written? I realize that these are hardly the questions most people associate with a man being swallowed by a giant fish, but as a historian, I simply cannot resist asking them first!

Who Wrote the Book of Jonah, and When?

This obscure prophet is the protagonist of the short book that bears his name, and because he was a prophet, that book is included in the collection of the twelve Minor Prophets. But unlike the books that surround it in the Bible, it contains few of the prophet's own words. Rather, it is a fictional narrative about the prophet... which uses satire and irony to convey a number of messages.

Who is Jonah in the Bible? The prophet Coogan refers to is Jonah, son of Amittai, who is briefly mentioned in 2 Kings 14:25 as a prophet active during the reign of the Israelite king Jeroboam II (c. 786–746 B.C.E.). 

Although this historical reference places Jonah in the 8th century BCE, it doesn’t establish when the book bearing his name was composed.

Indeed, contemporary scholarship generally distinguishes between the 8th-century prophet and the anonymous author responsible for the Book of Jonah.

The text itself provides no indication of its authorship, and there is no compelling evidence that Jonah, son of Amittai, wrote it. This naturally raises another question: when was the story of Jonah in the Bible actually written? 

Unfortunately, establishing a precise date is considerably more difficult than one might expect. 

Unlike several other prophetic books, Jonah contains no opening statement identifying the reign of a particular king or the historical circumstances in which its narrative takes place. 

Consequently, scholars have proposed dates ranging from the 8th century to the Hellenistic period, although many favor a composition sometime after the Babylonian exile, particularly during the Persian period (539–332 B.C.E.).

Several arguments support this later dating, although none is decisive. 

Some scholars point to the book's depiction of Nineveh, particularly its enormous size (Jonah 3:3) and the reference to the “king of Nineveh” (Jonah 3:6), suggesting that these details reflect an author writing long after the Assyrian city's destruction in 612 B.C.E.

Others emphasize linguistic features, including vocabulary and grammatical constructions associated with later biblical Hebrew, as well as possible Aramaic influences. 

Still others identify literary parallels with earlier biblical writings, including passages from Psalms, Jeremiah, and Joel, which could suggest that the author was drawing upon established scriptural traditions. 

Yet each argument has limitations. Nineveh's portrayal may serve a literary purpose rather than betray historical ignorance; linguistic features do not always permit precise dating; and similarities between biblical texts need not demonstrate direct literary dependence. 

Together, these considerations make a postexilic composition plausible, but they cannot establish it with certainty.

This uncertainty is particularly important because the question of when the book reached its present form isn’t necessarily the same as when stories about its protagonist first began circulating. 

Earlier oral or written traditions may have existed long before an anonymous author brought them together into the sophisticated narrative preserved in the Hebrew Bible. As Jack M. Sasson concludes in his Commentary on Jonah:

Despite its length, this report on the dating of Jonah is but a sample from a large literature on the topic. It must be evident that instead of helping us to pinpoint a definite date for Jonah, the survey leaves us with contestable clues about placing Jonah on either side of that great divide in Israel's history: the Exile-Restoration period (586-438). None of the arguments offered above, whether assessed singly or in tandem, is conclusive. Yet, if I am swayed by any of them, it is by the cumulative evidence collected above under the rubric ‘Literary and Linguistic Features.’ [located in the same book and chapter as this citation] It suggests that a final editing or composing of Jonah took place during the exilic, but more likely during the postexilic period.

NOW AVAILABLE!

Finding Moses: What Scholars Know About The Exodus &  The Jewish Law

Riveting and controversial, the "FINDING MOSES" lecture series takes you on a deep dive into the stories of Moses, the exodus, and a whole lot more...

Jonah and the Whale Story: Full of Irony and Satire

In his article “Laughing at the Bible: Jonah as Parody,” John A. Miles writes:

It is crucial to the functioning of parody that the literary style or styles to be laughed at be so standardized as to be immediately recognizable. The book of Jonah meets this requirement admirably, for the narrative of the prophetic career is surely the clearest stereotype in Scripture.

Although Miles published his article more than 40 years ago, his observations remain relevant to the way many biblical scholars interpret the Book of Jonah today. 

Rather than reading it primarily as a historical account of a prophet's extraordinary adventures, they approach it as a sophisticated literary narrative employing parody, irony, exaggeration, and satire. 

These devices are particularly evident in the episode that made Jonah famous: his encounter with an enormous sea creature. 

Interestingly, the familiar expression “Jonah and the whale” isn’t entirely accurate. The Hebrew text describes the creature simply as a dag gadol, meaning a “great fish” (1:17). The Greek Septuagint uses the word kētos, which could refer to a large aquatic creature, but neither text identifies a particular species.

This distinction matters because the biblical author appears considerably less interested in the creature's zoological identity than in its function within the narrative.

According to Jonah 1:17, God appoints the great fish to swallow Jonah after the sailors throw him overboard, and the prophet remains inside it for three days and three nights. 

The fish subsequently returns him to dry land (2:10), but not before Jonah offers a lengthy prayer of thanksgiving. 

Several literary details deserve attention here. 

First, the Hebrew verb manah, used to describe God's appointment of the fish, also appears when God appoints a plant, a worm, and a scorching wind in chapter 4. These repetitions establish a deliberate narrative pattern in which different elements of the natural world respond to divine direction. 

Second, Jonah's journey is characterized by a remarkable sequence of downward movements: he goes down to Jaffa, descends into the ship, retreats into its innermost parts, and finally plunges into the sea before ending up inside the fish.

The narrative thus turns the prophet's attempted escape into an increasingly dramatic descent. 

Third, the episode incorporates motifs familiar from ancient storytelling traditions, including being swallowed by an aquatic creature, surviving inside it, and eventually emerging alive. 

Such literary features suggest that asking whether a human being could biologically survive inside a whale or another large marine animal may not be the most productive question to bring to the text.

More revealing is the contrast between Jonah and the surrounding world: while the prophet repeatedly resists God's instructions, even a fish promptly fulfills its assigned role. For a narrative centered on a prophet who refuses to obey, the irony is difficult to miss.

Yet the most significant irony becomes apparent when we examine what Jonah actually does inside the fish.

Instead of describing the creature's interior or explaining how the prophet manages to survive, the author interrupts the narrative with a thanksgiving psalm (2:2–9).

As Douglas Stuart observes in his Hosea-Jonah Commentary, this prayer isn’t simply an awkward interruption of the story. Rather, it plays an important role in exposing the prophet's ethical inconsistency. 

Jonah sincerely thanks God for rescuing him from death, acknowledging the divine mercy that has preserved his life despite his disobedience. Stuart argues that the entire book is structured around the contrast between this gratitude and Jonah's subsequent reaction to the Ninevites.

In chapter 1, Jonah disobeys God and faces death; in chapter 2, he receives mercy and celebrates his deliverance. In chapter 3, the inhabitants of Nineveh respond to Jonah's warning and are likewise spared from destruction. 

Yet in chapter 4, rather than rejoicing over their survival, Jonah becomes furious. The same prophet who gratefully accepts mercy for himself cannot tolerate its extension to others. What makes this contradiction especially striking is that the fish, usually remembered as the terrifying creature that swallowed Jonah, actually functions as the instrument of his rescue.

Without it, Jonah would presumably have drowned. The extraordinary episode therefore becomes essential to the narrative's larger irony: Jonah benefits from precisely the kind of divine compassion that he later resents when it is shown to Nineveh.

This contrast helps explain why many scholars understand Jonah as a work of satire rather than merely an entertaining account of miraculous events. 

Throughout the narrative, expectations are repeatedly overturned: non-Israelite sailors respond more appropriately to divine activity than God's own prophet, an enormous city responds to a remarkably brief warning, and Jonah becomes more distressed over the destruction of a plant than over the possibility of an entire population being destroyed. 

The final episode involving the plant, worm, and scorching wind completes the pattern established by the fish. 

Once again, the natural world responds to God's direction, while Jonah struggles to understand what these events reveal about his own priorities. Stuart interprets the prophet's reaction as evidence of a narrowly restricted understanding of divine mercy, although the book's theological message isn’t necessarily exhausted by this interpretation.

The narrative also raises a broader question about the relationship between prophetic authority and divine freedom: what happens when God acts in ways that even his chosen prophet finds impossible to accept? 

Significantly, the book concludes without revealing Jonah's response to God's final question (4:11). The author leaves that question hanging, inviting readers to consider the contradictions that the narrative has exposed.

Seen from this perspective, the story's famous fish is only one element in a much more elaborate literary composition. 

The real object of the author's humor and criticism isn’t the improbability of surviving inside a sea creature, but the remarkable behavior of a prophet who understands God's mercy well enough to celebrate receiving it, yet cannot bear to see others enjoy the same privilege.

The Sign of Jonah: New Testament Reception

In his book The New Testament Interpretation of Scripture, Anthony T. Hanson writes:

The New Testament writers used an interpreted Bible, they did not expound the unadorned page of holy writ guided only by their knowledge of Jesus Christ. They approached Scripture, it is true, with strongly christocentric presuppositions, but they had all been brought up on Jewish traditions of exegesis, and except where their christocentric intentions interfered, they interpreted Scripture according to the technique which they had learned in Judaism. This does not imply that they had a monochromatic approach to Scripture, because the Jewish tradition of Scripture interpretation was not monochrome. But it does mean that they shared with their Jewish ancestors certain basic beliefs about Scripture and about the way in which one was justified in handling it.

Hanson's observation provides an important starting point for understanding how early Christians approached the Hebrew Scriptures. 

Rather than simply reproducing their contents, New Testament authors interpreted familiar biblical narratives in light of their convictions about Jesus. The story of Jonah in the Bible offers a particularly interesting example of this interpretive process.

In the Gospel traditions, Jonah appears in connection with Jesus' response to those demanding a sign from him. What is the sign of Jonah in the Bible?

Both Matthew (12:38–42; 16:4) and Luke (11:29–32) preserve versions of Jesus' reference to the “sign of Jonah,” although they explain its significance differently. 

In Matthew 12:40, Jesus declares that just as Jonah spent three days and three nights inside the great fish, the Son of Man will spend three days and three nights in the heart of the earth. Matthew thus establishes a typological correspondence between Jonah's extraordinary experience and Jesus' death and resurrection. 

The prophet's emergence from the fish becomes a narrative precedent through which Jesus' anticipated vindication can be understood. 

Luke, however, doesn’t explicitly associate Jonah's time inside the fish with Jesus' death, tomb, and resurrection. Instead, the emphasis falls on Jonah himself as a sign to the Ninevites, paralleling the role of the Son of Man for Jesus' contemporaries (11:30). 

This difference is particularly significant because it suggests that the Jonah tradition could be employed in more than one way within early Christian interpretations of Scripture.

The Matthean interpretation also raises an interesting historical and literary problem. As Steve Moyise explains in his book Jesus and Scripture: Studying the New Testament Use of the Old Testament:

This looks like it derives from the Church’s proclamation of the death and resurrection of Jesus as the focal point of salvation and judgement. However, the tradition (1 Cor. 15.3-4) was that Jesus rose on the third day (counting Friday as the first day), which makes the time period (‘three days and three nights’) incorrect. Matthew uses ‘on the third day’ in each of the Passion predictions (Matt. 16.21; 17.23; 20.19), and so it is unlikely that he would invent a saying that contradicts this. The saying is followed by a reference to the queen of the south visiting Solomon, and ends with the phrase ‘something greater than Solomon is here’ (Matt. 12.42). Thus the purpose of the saying is to assert the superiority of Jesus over Jonah, whom tradition regarded as an extraordinary prophet, and Solomon, the acknowledged expert when it comes to wisdom.

Moyise's analysis highlights the interpretive complexity of Matthew's use of Jonah: the correspondence between the two figures is not simply a matter of matching chronological details. 

It also serves Matthew's larger literary and theological purpose of presenting Jesus as surpassing revered figures from Israel's past.

Read alongside Luke's different emphasis, Matthew's account illustrates how early Christian authors could draw upon the same biblical story while adapting its significance to their particular presentations of Jesus.

jonah and the whale

Conclusion

Looking back at those childhood Sunday classes, I find it fascinating how a story that once captivated me through its colorful illustrations continues to intrigue me today, albeit for entirely different reasons. 

As a historian, I am now drawn less to the extraordinary image of a man swallowed by a giant fish and more to the literary sophistication of the ancient author who told his story. As we have seen, Jonah in the Bible is much more than a tale about a reluctant prophet and a miraculous fish. It is a narrative rich in irony, humor, and uncomfortable questions about divine mercy, human inconsistency, and the limits of prophetic understanding. 

Its reinterpretation by early Christian authors further illustrates its enduring literary and religious significance. And perhaps that is what makes this story so remarkable: the fish may be what captures our imagination, but it’s Jonah himself, with all his contradictions, who leaves us with something to think about long after we close the book.

NOW AVAILABLE!

Finding Moses: What Scholars Know About The Exodus &  The Jewish Law

Riveting and controversial, the "FINDING MOSES" lecture series takes you on a deep dive into the stories of Moses, the exodus, and a whole lot more...

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}